Cooking local game fish is a rewarding way to enjoy fresh, sustainable protein while celebrating regional flavors. Whether it’s trout from streams, bass from local ponds, pan fish, catfish from the river and ponds, or walleye from the lakes, local fish often taste better because they’re fresh and haven’t traveled far. Cooking them requires only simple methods to highlight their natural flavor.
Grilling is a favorite technique, especially for firm fish like bass or walleye. A hot grill and light seasoning—perhaps just salt, pepper, and lemon—let the fish’s natural taste shine through. For more delicate varieties like trout or perch, pan-frying in butter with herbs such as dill, thyme, or parsley enhances flavor without overpowering it.
Fish stews and chowders are another great way to use smaller fillets or leftover cuts. These dishes can include local vegetables, creating hearty meals that reflect the landscape and seasons. Smoking is also popular, especially with oily fish like largemouth bass or catfish, adding rich depth and preserving the catch. It’s important to clean and prepare game fish properly—removing scales, bones, and guts to ensure the best texture and flavor.
Fish recipes are far too numerous to even consider selecting a few to highlight. Instead, I will give a general breakdown of what some of the local species has to offer you. Frying, baking, smoking, and grilling are just a few of the many ways you can enjoy local catches. Adding your favorite seasonings and herbs will help you fix a fish meal that suites your own personal taste.
Trout: Trout is generally considered a delicious and healthy fish to eat. It’s known for its mild, delicate slightly nutty flavor, and flaky texture. Many people find it to be a versatile fish that can be cooked in various ways. The taste of trout can vary depending on certain bodies of water…the cleaner the water the more appealing the taste.
Walleye: Is a versatile fish that can be prepared in many ways. Walleye fillets are highly prized for their delicate flavor and are enjoyed in various dishes. It’s known for its mild, slightly sweet flavor and flaky texture, making it a favorite among freshwater fish enthusiasts.
Largemouth Bass: Largemouth bass is generally considered a good-tasting fish, but the flavor can vary. It is often described as having a mild, white, and flaky flesh, with a slightly fishy and oily taste. Some people find it delicious while others find it too fishy or oily, especially in larger or older fish. Factors like water quality and how the fish is prepared also play a role in its taste.
Smallmouth Bass: Smallmouth bass is generally considered a good fish to eat. It has a mild, slightly sweet flavor and firm, white flesh, similar to walleye. Some anglers even prefer it over largemouth bass due to its cleaner taste.
Catfish: The most common cooking method is deep-frying, but catfish can be grilled, baked and pan-fried with great success. Catfish has a mild, sweet flavor and is less flaky and denser than other white fish, allowing for a variety of cooking choices.
Panfish: Panfish is a term for small freshwater fish like bluegill, crappie, and perch. These fish are a popular choice for frying due to their size, which fits well in a frying pan. Panfish are excellent to eat. They have a delicate, mild, sweet, and flaky meat that is relatively easy to fillet. Panfish are often found in an easily accessible locations, making them an ideal option for anglers. The only down side is that you need several to make a meal.
Carp Recipe
Courtesy of special guest chef Fin Diesel
Grilled Cedar Planked Carp (Hold the Carp)
Ingredients:
• 1 (7-10 lb) fresh carp (preferably one that’s been giving you trouble)
• 1 green, rough-sawed cedar board
• Plenty of butter
• Aluminum foil
• Lemon juice (optional)
Instructions:
1. Find a good sturdy cedar board, preferably one that’s seen a few things.
2. Clean the carp thoroughly.
3. Liberally butter the carp, making sure to coat it completely.
4. Wrap the carp tightly in aluminum foil, ensuring no little fins poke out.
5. Nail the wrapped carp firmly to the cedar board. Don’t be shy.
6. Build a roaring fire in your firepit.
7. Place the cedar board with the nailed carp into the firepit.
8. Roast overnight.
9. Carefully unwrap the cooked carp (be careful, it’ll be hot!).
10. This is the critical step: Throw the carp away.
11. Serve the cedar plank (with a side of lemon juice if you like) and enjoy your culinary masterpiece.
